Victoria Government report overlooks impact of helmet law
A report entitled 'Developing Cycling as a Safe and Appealing Mode of Transport'
read more ...
Melbourne bikes still plagued by helmet law
Despite the Victoria State Government subsidising the sale of helmets from city c
read more ...
Fold-up helmet to save Melbourne bikes?
In a bid to save Melbourne's troubled bike share scheme, the state government is
read more ...
3 year old boy strangled by cycle helmet
A three-year-old boy in Adelaide, Australia has died after being strangled by the
read more ...
Ever-diminishing cycling a serious problem for children
Three decades ago most children rode bikes to school or walked — now only 5 per c
read more ...
The Victoria helmet law came into effect from July 1990. It applies to all ages.
The penalty for adults not wearing a 'securely fitted approved bicycle helmet', is usually a Bicycle Offence Penalty Notice, which is a fine. This started out at AUS 15, but by 2010 had increased massively to AUD 146.Government income from helmet offences is thought to exceed AUD 1 million annually. (The Age, 2010)
Not wearing a helmet is deemed by the Victorian legislature to be a more serious offence than maiming a cyclist through the careless opening of a vehicle door, for which the standard fine is AUD 122. (The Age, 2012)
Children receive a Bicycle Offence Report, which is a letter to their parents, without monetary penalty.
Introduction of the law resulted in a rise in cycle helmet use from 31% to 75% of cyclists.
The Victoria law is strictly enforced. In its first year 19,229 Bicycle Offence Penalty Notices and 5,028 Bicycle Offence Reports were issued. This represented 2.6% of all traffic offence notices, proportionally higher per kilometre than all other traffic offence notices together (King and Fraine, 1993). Even in the law's third year of operation, 86% of all traffic offences by cyclists were instancs of not wearing a helmet (AustCyclist, 1993).
In 2003 Victoria Police said that they still issue around 20,000 Bicycle Offence Penalty Notices a year. On 8th May 1996, Kathy Francis was imprisoned for 24 hours for not paying fines for not wearing a helmet. She was 40 years of age and 6 months pregnant at the time.
In 2012, 'Operation Halo' in Melbourne saw 351 cyclists fined for not wearing a helmet, against 262 being fined for all other offences put together (The Age, 2012b).
Admissions in the first four years of helmet legislation were 40% below the number expected on the basis of pre-legislation trends. However, there was no difference in the percentage with head injury, compared to what would have been expected without the law (Carr, Dyte and Cameron, 1995). In the first two years of the law % head injury for cyclists fell by only 1.7 percentage points, whereas % head injury for pedestrians (without helmets) fell by 2.5 percentage points. The gains in pedestrian safety have been attributed to general road safety initiatives which would also have benefited cyclists. It is therefore not possible to attribute any reduction in head injuries to the helmet law.
In Melbourne the number of cyclists sustaining severe injuries other than to the head was 4% and 12% lower in the first two post-law years compared with pre-law (Cameron, Newstead, Vulcan and Finch, 1994). These reductions are much less than the reduction in the number of cyclists and suggests that overall safety was reduced.
In 2009 it was reported that cycling injuries in Victoria had soared. Between 2001 and 2006 the number of cyclists attending emergency departments had increased by 42%, hospital admissions by 16% and major trauma by 76%. (Sikic et al, 2009) Over the same period commuter cycling across Victoria went up by about 33% (Victoria, 2008)
Bicycle use by children aged 5-17 decreased by 36% from May/June 1990 to May/June 1991 (Cameron, Heiman and Neiger, 1992). There were further falls to May/June 1992 in Melbourne, with teenage cycling showing by then a 46% decrease from pre-law levels (Finch, Heiman and Neiger, 1993).
3.4% of trips in Melbourne were by bicycle in 1985-6. In 2004 this had decreased to 2.0%. (ABC, 2004)
VicRoads carried out annual surveys of cyclists up to the enactment of the helmet law but the surveys stopped soon after.
From 2001 to 2006 commuter cycling increased by about 33%. This increase was almost entirely in the capital Melbourne and represented no change in the proportional share of transport that is cycling. The increase in cycle use was mainly due to population growth. All age groups witnessed an increase in commuter cycling except 15 to 24 year-olds for whom there was a fall. This is the age group known to be most sensitive to helmet laws. (Victoria, 2008)
Data published before introducing the helmet law indicated that there would be a benefit. However, it did not consider cycling being discouraged or other effects. There has been no post-law cost-benefit analysis.
The references below include additional related studies
Australia bicycle ownership and use. Australian Bicycle Council, 2004.
Vic Police target unhelmeted cyclists. Australian Cyclist, December 1993 p.17.
Cameron M, Finch C, Vulcan P, 1994. The Protective Performance of Bicycle Helmets introduced at the same time as the Bicycle Helmet Wearing Law in Victoria. Monash University Accident Research Centre Report 59.
Cameron M, Heiman L, Neiger D, 1992. Evaluation of the Bicycle Helmet Wearing Law in Victoria During its First 12 Months. Monash University Accident Research Centre Report 32.
Cameron M, Newstead S, Vulcan P, Finch C, 1994. Effects of the compulsory bicycle helmet wearing law in Victoria during its first three years. Monash University Accident Research Centre .
Cameron MH, Vulcan AP, Finch CF, Newstead SV, 1994. Mandatory bicycle helmet use following a decade of helmet promotion in Victoria, Australia - an evaluation. Accident Analysis & Prevention 1994;26(3):325-337.
Carr D, Dyte D, Cameron MH, 1995. Evaluation of the bicycle helmet wearing law in Victoria during its first four years. Monash University Accident Research Centre Report 76.
Finch C, Heiman L, Neiger D, 1993. Bicycle Use and Helmet Wearing Rates in Melbourne, 1987 to 1992: the influence of the helmet wearing law. Monash University Accident Research Centre Report 45.
Finch CF, Newstead SV, Cameron MH, Vulcan AP, 1993. Head injury reductions in Victoria two years after introduction of mandatory bicycle helmet use. Monash University Accident Research Centre Report 51.
King M, Fraine G, 1993. Bicycle helmet legislation and enforcement in Queensland 1991-3: effects on helmet wearing and crashes. Queensland Transport, Brisbane June 1993.
Morgan M, Peberdy J, Rogerson P, 1991. Bicycle helmet usage rates in Victoria, 1990 - 1991. Vic Roads GR91-9 ISBN 073061381X.
Newstead SV, Cameron MH, Gantzer S, Finch CF, 1994. Bicyclist Head Injuries in Victoria Three Years after the Introduction of Mandatory Helmet Use. Monash University Accident Research Centre Report 75.
Sikic M, Kikocka-Walus AA, Gabbe BJ, McDermott FT, Cameron PA, 2009. Bicycle injuries and mortality in Victoria, 2001 - 2006. Med J Aust 2009;190(7):353-356.
Riders left reeling by bike fine increase. The Age, 27 May 2010.
VicRoads baulks at 'dooring' demerit push . The Age, May 3 2012.
Helmet crackdown makes no sense. The Age, Mar 22 2012.
Walking and cycling: census analysis. Dept of Transport, Victoria, 2008.
Vulcan AP, Cameron MH, Heiman L, 1993. Mandatory bicycle helmet use - Victoria, Australia. Morbidity & Mortality Weekly Report 1993;42(18):359-363.
Vulcan AP, Cameron MH, Watson WL, 1992. Mandatory bicycle helmet use: experience in Victoria, Australia. World Journal of Surgery 1992;16:389-397.